Antico Pizza Battery Park

We tried the Diavola - It’s got spicy sopressata, buffalo mozzarella, garlic, and whole peppers. Most spicy pizzas are spicy in name only, but this one really packs a kick, especially when you get a bite of one of those peppers. Honestly we were skeptical about Antico when we first arrived - the pizzas are pricey, no fountain drinks, and their system is unusual (you order at the counter and they walk around calling your order number when it’s ready). But it’s all worth it once you try the pie. The cheese calzone was pretty good too, but wasn’t a standout. It also got a little black on top and eating the rest for leftovers left the outside breading tasting a little burnt which wasn't great. Stick to the pizza and it's a 5 star experience.

If you're looking for a delicious pizza in a cool environment, Antico Pizza is a great choice. The staff is friendly, and the condiments are top-notch. I'm not a fan of the 20%+ default tip for counter service, but other than that, Antico Pizza is a great spot.

Visited late after a concert and Antico was almost the only restaurant in The Battery still serving food. The line was long, but moved quickly and our pizza didn't take too long to come out. The pizza itself was very good. Also, there's a gelateria on site for a good dessert or treat while you're waiting for your pizza.

Been several times now and have never been disappointed. Every pizza is amazing. The bar tenders are all attentive and friendly. The pizzas are made quickly. They are large enough to share easily with 4 people. They have two cases of soft drinks as well. There is also a coffee and ice cream caffe. There's a 10% discount for employees in the Battery. Ask for the meatballs. They are a hidden menu specialty that come with flat bread and are soooo good. Prices are fairly reasonable as well. Highly recommend.

Great atmosphere. Those wood burning ovens sometimes work too well. Or maybe our pizza was left in a little too long. The taste was great. I wish they weren't so stingy with the topping. Oh! The beer was good and cold just the way I like it.