San Carlo Osteria Piemonte

This place was amazing
The place is clean, decent, with high ceilings and captivating decorations that are picture-perfect. The service is quick and reliable. Their food is delicious and reasonably priced. This is my ideal restaurant.
I highly recommend this place to everyone.

Writing review from December 5- I really hope they open up again! Food was amazing and the servers were knowledgeable and patient with wine selection. I had accidentally ordered a meal with meat in it (vegetarian) and they were very understanding. The soups were fantastic, can’t wait to return

Fantastic food and ambiance. You truly cannot go wrong with the pastas and the Veal Milanese. I recommend sharing a pasta first and then share the Veal as the main course.

UPDATE: At this point, I think I’ve tried everything on the menu and there is not one bad dish. The absolute best Italian food in NYC.

Ok place.
Outside setup isn’t something wow. Food is good, but portions are small for the price. Vitello tonato was chewy, beef tartar 5 out of 5, pasta with rabbit
- again, ok but nothing wow. Server was nice, but service in general wasn’t attentive. The brought food without silverware, water glasses were smelly, most likely wiped with not fresh cloth. Service was fast tho. Was it bad? No it wasn’t. Was it wow? Not really.
But have to mention that when we told server about water glass they removed water from the bill. So they actually hear what you are saying and want to help this is always a good sign. Overall it’s a good place, but needs work on decor and and a little of staff raining.
Come for beef tartar 😍

Great food and good vibes!